◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)◇◇

刘登义副校长的“SCI论文”还有假

作者：路见不平

尊敬的方先生：

　　我是《新语丝》忠实的读者，十分痛恨学术腐败！看了您的《安徽师范大学
常务副校长刘登义如此成批伪造论文发表记录》 (XYS20051203)一文，顺便上网
查了一下，发现情况比您揭露的更为严重，现将新发现的关于刘登义副校长弄虚
作假情况补充如下。

　　从安徽师范大学生命科学学院网页
（http://www.ahnu.edu.cn/shengming/daoshi/liudy.htm）中可看出刘登义共
有8篇SCI收录文章：

　　1．Elmqvist, T., Liu, D(刘登义)., Carlsson, U. and Giles, B.E. 1993. 
Oikos 68:207-216.
　　2．Liu, D(刘登义) and Ericson, L. 1993. Ecology 81:263-270. 
　　3.    Liu, D(刘登义). 1995. Oikos. 74:98-106.
　　4. Liu, D(刘登义). and Ericson, L. 2000. Ecol. 81(8):2341-2347.
　　5. Liu, D(刘登义). and Ericson, L. 2001. Am. J. Bot. 101(4):623-631.
　　6.   Liu, D(刘登义). and Ericson, L. 2002. Acta Botanica Sinica(植
物学报)，44(1):88-96.
　　7.  Liu, D(刘登义) and Lars, E. 2000. Ecol.  81(8):2315-2322.
　　8.  Liu, D(刘登义) and You bao, W. 2003. Bulletin of Environmental 
Contamination And Toxicology，71(5):1011-1018.

　　方先生已指出其中4篇有假（3篇Ecol.和1篇Am. J. Bot.），本人查出另2篇
有假。

　　Oilos是在生态学领域非常有影响的杂志，2004年Impact Factor为2.901。
经ISI web of knowledge使用BIOSIS Previews数据库搜索，无法查到“Liu, 
D(刘登义). 1995. The correlation of infection by parasitic fungus and 
disease history of host plant. Oikos. 74:98-106”一文，该数据库共收录
Oikos1988年以来的所有论文ABSTRACT。相近页码的文章是： Baldy, Virginie; 
Gessner, Mark O.; Chauvet, Eric Bacteria, fungi and the breakdown of 
leaf litter in a large river Oikos 74 (1) : 93-102 1995

　　Acta Botanica Sinica(植物学报)现已改名为“Journal of Integrative 
Plant Biology”（被引频次和影响因子多年来在我国生物类期刊中名列前茅），
被 SCI Search收录。经查刘登义植物学报一文（2002）和他当第二作者的Oikos
（1993）一文的ABSTRACT雷同，不同的是Oikos原文三个作者Elmqvist, T. ，
Carlsson, U. and Giles, B.E均不见，换上了Ericson。我手头没有刘登义发表
在《植物学报》上的全文，望知情者比较二者的全文。

附件1.植物学报一文的ABSTRACT

Infection of the Anther-smut Microbotryum violaceum in Populations of 
Silene dioica:Variation in Floral Morphology, Patterns of Spore 
Deposition and Pathogen-Pollinator Mediated Selection
Author: LIU Deng-Yi*, Ulla CARLSSON
 The anther-smut Microbotryum violaceum (Brandenburger and Schvinn) G. 
Deml. and Oberw.) causes a systemic infection of its host Silene 
dioica (L.) Clairv., resulting in sterility and production of 
teliospores (dispersal propagules) in flowers. These spores are 
transmitted to healthy plants mainly by flower visitors. The 
behavioral responses of flower visitors to a variation in floral 
characters, are not only likely to affect rates of pollen export/import, 
but also the rate of spore deposition and probability of disease. In a 
transplantation experiment, using plants from four different 
populations, we tested for correlation between variation in female 
floral morphology and patterns of spore and pollen deposition, and a 
resulting risk of disease. The source populations in this experiment 
were located on four islands in Skeppsvik archipelago in northern 
Sweden, and represented a gradient of disease incidence from 
completely healthy (Island 1), low incidence (Island 2) to 
highincidences (Islands 3 and 4) of disease. Fifty plants from each 
population were transplanted to the center of the population on Island 
4. There were significant differences among the transplants in floral 
characters, i.e. corolla size, style length and ovule number. Plants 
from the non-diseased population had larger flowers and longer styles 
than plants from the highly diseased populations. Numbers of pollen 
grains and spores deposited on flowers were strongly and positively 
correlated. We found that plants originating from the non-diseased 
population captured approximately 4 times more pollen and 9 times more 
spores per flower than the individuals from the resident population 
(Island 4, population 4). The incidences of disease among plants from 
the four populations differed significantly,
and was 37%, 20%, 18% and 0 for populations 1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively. 
In a survey of ten populations we found a significant negative 
correlation between the mean style length (positively correlated with 
corolla size and ovule number) among healthy plants and incidence of 
disease in these populations. The potentiality for pathogen-pollinator 
mediated selection on floral characters and consequences for gene flow 
between populations of Silene dioica are discussed.

附件2. OIKOS一文的ABSTRACT
Title: Anther-smut infection in Silene dioica: Variation in floral 
morphology and patterns of spore deposition
Author(s): Emlqvist, Thomas; Liu, D.; Carlsson, Ulla; Giles, Barbara E. 
Source: Oikos 68 (2) : 207-216 1993
Abstract: The anther-smut Microbotryum violaceum, causes a systemic 
perennial infection of its host Silene dioica. Infection results in 
sterility and the production of teliospores in flowers. These spores 
are transmitted to healthy plants by flower visiting insects. The 
behavioural responses of flower visiting insects to a variation in 
floral characters are therefore likely to affect rates of pollen 
export/import, the rate of spore deposition and probability of disease. 
Since infected plants are sterilized, they are effectively removed 
from the gene pool. It is therefore often assumed that in this 
host-pathogen system there is a considerable potential for a 
pathogen-pollinator mediated selection on floral characters. In a 
transplantation experiment, which included plants from four different 
populations, we tested for correlations between variation in female 
floral morphology and patterns of spore and pollen deposition, and a 
resulting risk of disease. The source populations in this experiment 
were located on four islands in Skeppsvik archipelago in northern 
Sweden, and represented a gradient of disease incidence from 
completely healthy (Island 1), low incidence (Island 2) to high 
incidences (Islands 3 and 4) of disease. Fifty plants front each 
population were transplanted to the centre of the population on Island 
4. Plants from the non-diseased population had larger flowers and 
longer styles than plants from the highly diseased populations. 
Numbers of pollen grains and spores deposited on flowers were strongly 
and positively correlated. We found that plants originating from the 
healthy population received approximately four times more pollen and 
nine times more spores per flower than the individuals from the 
resident diseased population. The resulting incidences of disease 
among plants from the four Populations differed significantly, and was 
20% among plants originating from the healthy population and 0% among 
plants from the resident highly diseased population. Plants from the 
other two diseased populations showed intermediate values (13% and 11% 
respectively). In a survey of ten populations we found among healthy 
plants a significant negative correlation between mean style length 
(positively correlated with corolla size and ovule number) and 
incidence of disease. The potential for pathogen-pollinator mediated 
selection on floral characters in this host-pathogen system is 
discussed.

(XYS20051205)

◇◇新语丝(www.xys.org)(xys.dxiong.com)(xys.3322.org)(xys.xlogit.com)◇◇